• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Jimtown Pizza – Authentic Northern Indiana Pizzeria with Hand-Scooped Ice Cream in Elkhart

Jimtown Pizza, nestled in Elkhart, Indiana, is a local gem known for its authentic northern Indiana charm. This unassuming spot delivers delicious, hand-crafted pizzas that capture the true flavor of Jimtown. Their menu also features tasty appetizers and a variety of hand-scooped ice creams, adding a delightful twist to the dining experience. Friendly staff enhance the warm, community feel, making each visit welcoming and enjoyable. Though modest and off the beaten path, Jimtown Pizza stands out for its quality, quick service, and affordable prices—perfect for those craving genuine, comforting flavors in a relaxed setting.

Jimtown Pizza at a glance

  • Address 59176 Co Rd 3, Elkhart, IN 46517, United States
  • Phone +1 574-295-5142
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Jimtown Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

AMcLeod timetraveler3
4

I love this kind of place, authentic to Jimtown and to northern Indiana. Definitely off the beaten track, which makes it special. Better still, several varieties of hand scooped ice cream. Good prices too!

Cindy Mansfield
5

Excellent pizza! Friendly staff!!! Will definitely be back

Jimi Escalante
5

They need to take a day to clean the place it's covered in dust and needs some paint. But the pizza is good. And btw a stromboli isnt made on sandwich bread. That was just a cheese and sauce sandwich

jim hodge
5

Hidden gem in Jimtown. It was really good food and ready quickly for pickup. I'll be back for more next time I'm in the area.

Aaron Koszyk
5

Great pizza, appetizers, and ice cream!!! The staff is always very friendly!

Seth Jordan
5

Tastes just like my childhood favorite (Cooks Pizza, WHEN THERE WERE THE ORIGINAL OWNERS) and the consistency from one day to the next is top notch! Always made right and always the same great quality and taste!!

Bradd Neidhamer
5

There is something in the sauce. Gotta be grandmas secret recipe!

Location

  • Jimtown Pizza
    Jimtown Pizza
    59176 Co Rd 3, Elkhart, IN 46517, United States Hotline: +1 574-295-5142

Jimtown Pizza, tucked away in the heart of Elkhart, Indiana, feels like a true local treasure. This unassuming spot off the beaten path captures the spirit of northern Indiana with every bite. The pizza here isn’t just good—it’s a hearty, honest representation of regional flavors that invite you to slow down and savor. The crust strikes a perfect balance of crisp and chew, while the sauce and cheese meld into a comforting harmony that keeps you coming back for more.

Beyond the pizza, Jimtown Pizza surprises with hand-scooped ice cream in several varieties, adding a sweet finish to your meal. It’s the kind of place where you find simple pleasures done right—friendly staff ready to greet you, quick service for pickup, and prices that respect your wallet.

While some might notice the need for a bit of upkeep in decor, it hardly distracts from the experience. The focus remains firmly on food that feels authentic and heartfelt. If you’re drawn to genuine local eateries with character and soul, Jimtown Pizza offers an inviting slice of northern Indiana worth discovering.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in